The Best Barrell Craft Spirits Bottles We've Reviewed, Ranked
Bourbon Culture is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Updated November 2026. This list now covers every Barrell Craft Spirits bottle we have reviewed and scored: 100 bottles, ranked strictly by their Bourbon Culture score. The original version of this article, published in 2023, ranked our favorites from 2020 to 2023. The method has changed, and so has most of the list. Scores keep their original tasting context and have not been re-scored. Where bottles are tied on score, the earlier review ranks first.
Barrell Craft Spirits has undergone massive changes over the years. The Private Release program has exploded, there is now a Gold Label tier for premium bourbon and rye whiskey and the named releases keep on coming after the success of Dovetail in late 2018.
The brand has even purchased its first warehouse for storage and is well on their way to filling it all up.
How This Ranking Works
The first version of this list was a favorites list, and favorites drift. This version is simpler: if we reviewed it and scored it, it is eligible, and the highest scores win. That cuts both ways. A few bottles we still reach for, like Barrell Vantage and Barrell Bourbon Batch 024, fall off the list because other bottles scored higher. And a few older limited releases that a three-year favorites window skipped, like the 25 Year Whiskey, finally get their due.
One housekeeping note: Stellum bottles are eligible. Stellum is a division of Barrell Craft Spirits, and its Black Rye has been near the top of our Barrell scores since we reviewed it.
New Blends with Big Impacts
Barrell has begun to blend new whiskies into their blends over the years that have created big impacts in how their products taste.
They’ve finally sourced wheated bourbon from both Barton (think 1792 Sweet Wheat) and MGP. They’ve used wheated bourbon from Wyoming Whiskey and MGP’s 99/1 bourbon mash bill. They’ve even sourced Canadian whiskey (and rye whiskey) and have been putting it in a ton of different releases from their new Private Release Rye Whiskey line to Seagrass and Dovetail Gold.
With so much variety, there is something for every enthusiast. That also makes it harder to decide which ones you should spend your money on. This is why I’ve decided to simplify it all and give you a list of the top 10 you should buy if you’re Barrell-curious.
As much as I hate writing something that sounds like a listicle (trust me, I want to distance myself as far away as I can from Uproxx or Forbes), this is in the spirit of helping you out.
After all, at the Bourbon Culture, we pride ourselves on having reviewed every batched Barrell product since Bourbon Batch 001. Make sure to follow us for reviews on all of the upcoming stuff Barrell is putting out too!
#10 Barrell Bourbon Batch 009

Read our review for Barrell Bourbon Batch 009 here
Our score: 8.5/10
Batch 009 is built on barrels sourced from Dickel, and our review called it quite possibly one of the best batches of Dickel barrels Barrell has ever worked with. Tobacco leaf and a somewhat bitter oak add depth against all the sweetness, and the finish runs layered and long with sweet mint, cherry lozenges, cinnamon-spiced honey and saddle leather.
The review's verdict was simple: this is the epitome of what an aged whiskey should be.
#9 Barrell Dovetail

Read our review for Barrell Dovetail here
Our score: 8.5/10
Dovetail is the finished whiskey that put Barrell on the map for a lot of drinkers, and it still holds up. Our review found sweet plums, buttery pie crust and cherry pie filling alongside golden raisins and lemon curd, with baking spices that build in intensity without ever getting too hot.
It was the first Barrell bottle our reviewer immediately went out and bought a second of. It also has a habit of converting drinkers who swear they do not like finished whiskey.
#8 Barrell Bourbon 10th Anniversary Blend

Read our review for the Barrell Bourbon 10th Anniversary Blend here
Our score: 8.6/10
Released to mark ten years of Barrell Craft Spirits, this blend took a few pours over several days to show itself. Our review found that it settled into a competent and complex blend, with the blueberry and cola notes our reviewer associates with elite bourbons.
The finish is long and cooling, with menthol, leather and oak over vanilla custard, cherry pie filling and orange preserves.
#7 Stellum Black Rye

Read our review for Stellum Black Rye here
Our score: 8.6/10
Wait, how can #1 be a non-Barrell product? It actually is a Barrell product! If you don’t already know this, Stellum is the newest division of Barrell Craft Spirits. The purpose of a new line was to create whiskies that were more consistent batch-to-batch rather than Barrell’s “every batch is different” philosophy.
This bottle of Stellum Black Rye is not any cheaper than a typical batch of Barrell (still about $100) but there’s a reason it’s on top of the list: because it’s incredible for what it is.
Stellum Black Rye uses components that, by themselves, would probably be unremarkable. But it’s how they blend them together that makes a rye whiskey that is very much more than the sum of its parts.
Together, it creates a rye whiskey that has the sweetness of a Kentucky rye, the spice, citrus and herbal qualities of an Indiana rye and the mellow character of a Tennessee rye. It is the complete package.
Plus the fact it’s bottled at barrel proof means that it’s flavor is already at peak capacity once you pour it into your glass. It’s really got it all which is why it won the top spot on my Most Memorable Whiskies of 2022 wrap-up last year.
Look for its offshoots (like this Fibonacci Blend #1) too for something slightly different from the standard Black Rye bottling. This is one of the most consistently delicious bottles on the market and I don’t even know who else comes close for the price.
#6 Barrell Seagrass

Read our review for Barrell Seagrass here
Our score: 8.7/10
I want to clarify that the regular Barrell Seagrass that I’m putting ahead of Barrell Seagrass Gold isn’t because it’s the better whiskey, but it is when you compare them based on value.
There simply isn’t a better finished rye whiskey on the market for the price than Barrell Seagrass Gold. If this was a list that just said “Top 10 Whiskies since 2020,” Barrell Seagrass would still be on it.
In fact, it finished in second place in my Top 10 Most Memorable Whiskies of 2021 write up. I liked it that much.
Don’t take this next part as a fact, just an observation, but I’d estimate that only ⅓ of bourbon drinkers like rye whiskey. Perhaps if more of them tried Barrell Seagrass, they’d change their attitudes. It’s the perfect bottle for a person who is on the fence about rye whiskey.
It knows that those kinds of people might not like the bold spices or floral/herbal notes that come along with it. That’s okay because the Rum, Apricot Brandy and Madeira cask finishes provide plenty of additional sweetness with loads of fruit.
It’s become one of Barrell’s bestselling products and it’s not even close. There’s a reason for that, it’s a bottle that can be so many things for so many different people. If your whiskey cabinet does not have a Barrell product in it yet, this should be the first one.
#5 Barrell Craft Spirits Gold Label Dovetail

Read our review for Barrell Craft Spirits Gold Label Dovetail here
Our score: 8.9/10
The Gold Label version of Dovetail takes the original's finished profile and turns the intensity up. Our review found strawberry-rhubarb pie with a sugared crust, orange and lemon citrus and cinnamon spice, all through a finish that lasts a long time.
It is a concentrated pour. A few sips were enough to wipe out our reviewer's palate, but unlike other big bottles that punish you for it, this one stayed gentle in its approach.
#4 Barrell Craft Spirits 15 Year Bourbon (2018)

Read our review for the Barrell Craft Spirits 15 Year Bourbon here
Our score: 9.0/10
This score comes from our joint review of the 2018 and 2019 Gray Label 15 Year releases, tasted side by side with Danny Burke of Oak and Time. Both reviewers had the 2018 clearly ahead. Mike's notes found almond butter, cedar cigar box, vanilla buttercream, cherry pie filling and dark chocolate, with a long finish of chocolate, leather and tobacco.
Mike scored the 2018 release a 9.0 (Danny scored it 8.5). The 2019 release scored 8.2, and sits further down our full list.
#3 Barrell Single Barrel 13 Year Rye Whiskey

Read our review for the Barrell Single Barrel 13 Year Rye here
Our score: 9.0/10
A single barrel of 13 year old rye whiskey, and one of the highest-scored ryes we have ever published. Our review found green apple skin, cherry licorice and Red Hots candy that fade into a rye spice that warms more than it burns.
The finish is sour apple candy for days, with a refreshing mint and menthol cooling effect. Our reviewer credits this bottle with sparking his passion for rye whiskey.
#2 Barrell Craft Spirits Gold Label Seagrass

Read our review for Barrell Seagrass Gold Label here
Our score: 9.3/10
I feel like I should not be including a $500 bottle on this list. It is not something you just casually go out and buy. This is a bottle for special occasions and special friends.
Seagrass Gold takes a 20 year old Canadian rye whiskey that has a surprising amount of oak in it and adds complementary layers of finishes that leave the final product like drinking a rich syrup of rye and fruit.
My friends who have tried this have all generally agreed, this is a BTAC-level bottle in terms of how good it is. So while I didn’t want to put it on my list, I changed my mind because this is actually something that is out there on store shelves right now.
The price is high, but it’s not higher than a bottle of Thomas H. Handy on the secondary (upwards of $650). It’s also lower than the price of the newest Whistlepig Boss Hogs which it also competes with (that one is also $650).
So while it is spendy, you are kind of getting a deal depending on how you look at it. It’s a fantastic product that beats its competitors in flavor and value.
The best part is there’s no threat of a secondary market scammer taking your money and running. It’s amazing how good it is, just make sure to drink this one slowly, the finish is unbelievably long.
#1 Barrell Craft Spirits 25 Year Whiskey (2018)

Read our review for the Barrell Craft Spirits 25 Year Whiskey here
Our score: 9.5/10
The highest-scored Barrell bottle we have ever reviewed. Built on ultra-aged corn whiskey, it layers softer oak notes and herbal notes that drift in and out over the base distillate. Our review called it magical: the kind of whiskey that introduces you to flavors and scents you have never experienced before.
The only deduction was a finish that runs medium in length rather than long. Barrell released it to most markets at $350, per our review, and it did not sit on shelves for long.
Two more bottles scored 8.5 and missed the cut only on the tiebreak: Barrell Rye Whiskey Batch 003 and Barrell Craft Spirits Gold Label Bourbon. Right behind them at 8.4 are Barrell Bourbon Batch 005 and Stellum Black Rye Fibonacci Blend #1. Every one of the 100 scores is on our Reviews by Rating page.





Funny how tastes and palates vary. My absolute favorite from this period, Batch 28, didn’t even make the list.