Mister Sam Tribute Whiskey (Batch 4, 2025) Review
I have been hounded for my review of the fourth installment of the biggest secret in the whiskey world: Mister Sam. So here it is.

Buffalo Trace Distillery is a distillery located in Frankfort, Kentucky that produces a variety of spirits, including bourbon, rye whiskey, and vodka. It was founded in 1773 and is one of the oldest continuously operating distilleries in the United States.
The distillery is named after the historic buffalo trace, a centuries-old pathway used by buffalo and other animals to travel through the region.
Buffalo Trace is known for producing high-quality, award-winning spirits using traditional methods and ingredients. The distillery uses corn, rye, and barley in its mash bills and ages its spirits in charred oak barrels.
Some of the distillery’s most popular products include Buffalo Trace Bourbon, Eagle Rare Bourbon, Blanton’s Bourbon, and Pappy Van Winkle, which are highly sought after by collectors and whiskey enthusiasts.
I have been hounded for my review of the fourth installment of the biggest secret in the whiskey world: Mister Sam. So here it is.
Did Buffalo Trace really need to introduce a sixth label to the Antique Collection? Or is there something more at play here?
Enthusiasts may fawn over the OG 2006 release of Thomas H Handy, but it’s the 2007 that has more impressive numbers.
So we meet again, Stapleton…
William Larue Weller probably needs no introduction at this point. It’s the only wheated bourbon in the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection. The liquid inside shows what can happen when their …
A recount of the December 18th Slacker Advent Calendar blind reveal and group notes!
A recount of the December 3rd Slacker Advent Calendar blind reveal and group notes!
I know that many of my readers are currently in the middle of participating in a Bourbon Advent Calendar while I’m sure other readers have never heard of this concept …
Which bottles are hits and which are misses? The secondary market is the best marker to find out.
An unassuming bottle from 2006 holds a few secrets that become apparent upon the first sip.
Seriously, how much better than the 10-year version can this be?
What we know a month later from the flood that impacted Buffalo Trace
Will floods and tariffs create the perfect storm for allocated bottles this fall?
After a 2 year delay, we’re finally getting a product that could change our minds about EH Taylor’s bland “Straight Rye” label.
The 2023 version of Buffalo Trace Antique Collection’s only barrel proof rye whiskey
A cheesy gold label… is this what I think it is?
The rare single barrel of Special Reserve pops up from an unlikely store in Indianapolis
The 2017 release of George T. Stagg
Does the unbelievable price make it an unbelievable whiskey?
The very first Weller CYPB release
The top of the Pappy foodchain
One of the last batches of Stagg to be released in 2023.
A case study in Seagram’s exceptional quality control handed down throughout the years
Buffalo Trace did a lot more than just take away the “Jr”
April Showers bring May flowers. So what do May flowers bring? New Weller releases
Ranking the 7 most common types of Blanton’s so you can focus on the best!
The final installment of the Blanton’s Takara Single Barrel lineup
Takara Red is the Japanese equivalent to our standard Blanton’s Single Barrel – but is it that different?
Exploring the lowest-priced option of the three Blanton’s Takara releases
Buffalo Trace wants to sell you the experience of a lifetime
The oldest, annually-released rye whiskey money can buy
The internet is already filled with crap. AI-generated bourbon reviews just adds more sewage to the mix.
The black sheep of the Van Winkle family of whiskies
2 updates on Elijah Craig Barrel Proofs and some other bottle news
Lots of Jim Beam news, C923 Batch info missing and membership programs!
Incredible. Amazing. “Whiskey of the Year.” None of these words would be used to describe Traveller Whiskey.
2023 was a year highlighted by wars. Ukraine, Israel and the Noblesville Indiana Costco Full Proof release
If you thought Weller was expensive before, you ain’t seen nothing yet!
Got $10k burning a hole in your pocket? I’ve got the whiskey for you!
The original version of Pappy Van Winkle Bourbon