Best Whiskeys Under $100

Best whiskeys under $100 selected by The Bourbon Culture
Affiliate disclosure

Bourbon Culture is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Finding a great whiskey for less than $100 isn't particularly difficult. Finding one that's actually worth the asking price is another story.

We've reviewed hundreds of whiskeys at The Bourbon Culture, from everyday shelf bottles to limited releases that disappear almost as soon as they arrive. Some of the best pours we've had cost less than $100 at retail, while plenty of more expensive bottles have left us wondering where the extra money went.

For this list, we're looking strictly at whiskeys we've personally reviewed and scored, ranked from highest to lowest on our 10-point scale. We're using retail prices, not secondary-market asking prices. And when a bottle is allocated, discontinued, or nearly impossible to find, that's worth knowing before you start hunting.

Members read ad-free

Enjoying this? Read the whole site ad-free.

No ads, plus the full Brown Book and member downloads.

Go ad-free — $3/mo

Best Whiskeys Under $100 at a Glance

RankWhiskeyOur ScoreRetail PriceAvailability
1Jack Daniel’s Tanyard Hill Rye8.9$79.99Limited release
2Elijah Craig Barrel Proof8.8$74.99Ongoing line, batches vary
3Four Roses Private Selection8.8$75.00Barrel-specific
4Stagg Jr Single Barrel8.7$90.00Allocated
5A. Smith Bowman Cask Strength Batch 48.5$99.99Limited
6Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel8.3$69.99Generally available
7Eagle Rare Aged 12 Years8.2$49.99Allocated
8Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye8.2$69.99Availability varies
9Remus Repeal Reserve IX8.2$99.99Limited release
10Larceny Barrel Proof8.1$64.99Ongoing line

1. Jack Daniel's Special Release Tanyard Hill Rye (2025)

Our Score: 8.9/10 | Retail: $79.99

Jack Daniel's 2025 Tanyard Hill Rye whiskey bottle

I genuinely believe this is the best rye whiskey Jack Daniel's has ever released. There's an incredible amount of sweetness here, with maple candy, banana bread, chocolate-dipped candy canes, butter toffee and even a Dr Pepper-like note that makes the whole experience more interesting. The mouthfeel is thick and oily, the heat is surprisingly manageable, and I had a hard time finding anything to complain about.

The bad news? This was a limited release, and finding one anywhere near $80 is going to take some serious luck.

Read our Tanyard Hill Rye review

2. Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Bourbon

Our Score: 8.8/10 | Retail: $74.99

Elijah Craig Barrel Proof has been one of the better values in high-proof bourbon for years. The Batch 6 bottle that earned our 8.8 score was an absolute monster, loaded with melted candy bar, toffee, nuts and enough mature oak to remind you why enthusiasts still chase those old squat bottles. It was rich, sweet and powerful without letting the heat completely take over.

Just remember that our 8.8 belongs to the historical Batch 6 release, not every bottle of Elijah Craig Barrel Proof sitting on shelves today. Current batches are still worth considering, but their scores and flavor profiles vary.

Read our Elijah Craig Barrel Proof review

3. Four Roses Private Selection

Our Score: 8.8/10 | Retail: $75.00

Four Roses Private Selection OESV bourbon

I've always had a soft spot for Four Roses Private Selections, and the 2024 Father's Day OESV release was something special. The nose brought rich oak, molasses, cocoa and citrus, while the palate delivered cherries, dates, licorice and enough spice to keep everything interesting. What impressed me most was how the age and proof worked together without turning the bourbon into an oak bomb.

This score belongs to one exceptional OESV barrel, so don't expect every Private Selection to taste exactly like it. That's part of the fun of single barrels, though.

Read our Four Roses Private Selection review

4. Stagg Jr Single Barrel Bourbon

Our Score: 8.7/10 | Retail: $90.00

Most people expect Stagg Jr to deliver cherries, caramel, oak and a healthy dose of heat. The Binny's single barrel we reviewed threw that expectation out the window, replacing much of the familiar profile with nougat, chocolate, floral notes and rye-like spices. There was even a wood polish character that reminded me more of Old Forester than Buffalo Trace.

It was one of the most unusual Stagg Jr bottles I've tasted, and that's exactly why I enjoyed it so much. Unfortunately, these single barrels are heavily allocated, and $90 is more of a hunting target than a price you're likely to encounter.

Read our Stagg Jr Single Barrel review

5. A. Smith Bowman Cask Strength Batch 4 (2025)

Our Score: 8.5/10 | Retail: $99.99

If you love George T. Stagg but don't love what it costs to acquire one, A. Smith Bowman Cask Strength deserves your attention. Batch 4 is loaded with cherries and chocolate, backed by caramel, mature oak, leather and just enough spice to keep the sweetness in check. Despite its substantial proof, it drinks considerably easier than you'd expect.

I thought this was getting awfully close to George T. Stagg territory, which is about the highest compliment I can give a bourbon in this price range. Of course, actually finding one for $100 is another matter.

Read our A. Smith Bowman Cask Strength Batch 4 review

6. Russell's Reserve Single Barrel Bourbon

Our Score: 8.3/10 | Retail: $69.99

Russell's Reserve Single Barrel bourbon bottle

I've collected enough Russell's Reserve single barrels to know that some can taste remarkably similar. The 2022 "Recreational Cough Syrup" pick was anything but ordinary, with peach, raspberry preserves, orange zest and a creamy mouthfeel that made it stand apart from the usual Wild Turkey profile. The mature oak and cherry notes were still there, but the extra fruit character made this barrel particularly memorable.

The specific barrel we reviewed is long gone, but Russell's Reserve Single Barrel remains one of the more practical bottles on this list to look for at retail. Just remember that individual barrels can vary considerably.

Read our Russell's Reserve Single Barrel review

7. Eagle Rare Aged 12 Years

Our Score: 8.2/10 | Retail: $49.99

I wanted to find something wrong with Eagle Rare 12, but Buffalo Trace made that awfully difficult. The extra maturity brings seasoned oak, leather, toffee and dark fruit into a profile that still feels unmistakably Eagle Rare. It has considerably more depth than the standard 10-year-old, with enough sweetness and spice to keep the oak from taking over.

At $50, I'd happily drink this regularly. Unfortunately, so would everybody else, which explains why finding one at retail remains such a challenge.

Read our Eagle Rare 12 Year review

8. Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye

Our Score: 8.2/10 | Retail: $69.99

Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye whiskey

Jack Daniel's has become one of my favorite producers of high-proof rye whiskey, and this single barrel helped reinforce that opinion. Caramel, peppermint, cherry, apricot and baking spices all show up, along with an unexpected touch of chocolate. It drinks hot, but the heat adds to the experience rather than ruining it.

What surprised me most was how clearly the rye character came through compared to the earlier limited release. If you enjoy rye whiskey with plenty of sweetness and a little attitude, this is an easy bottle to recommend.

Read our Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye review

9. Remus Repeal Reserve IX

Our Score: 8.2/10 | Retail: $99.99

I've enjoyed several Remus Repeal Reserve releases, but Batch IX brought something different to the table. Alongside the familiar brown sugar, oak and baking spices were jammy fruits, chocolate and a strange nutty, oxidized character that reminded me of a sherry-cask influence. It was a welcome change from the more straightforward profiles of previous releases.

I consider this one of the best entries in the series, and the balance between fruit and mature oak is a big reason why. If you come across Batch IX at retail, I'd have no problem recommending it.

Read our Remus Repeal Reserve IX review

10. Larceny Barrel Proof Bourbon

Our Score: 8.1/10 | Retail: $64.99

Sometimes a bourbon doesn't need to surprise you to be good. Batch C923 delivered exactly what I wanted from a high-proof Heaven Hill wheated bourbon: caramel, chocolate, cherries, citrus, brown sugar and a nice amount of oak. It's one of the better values here, especially since the ongoing line is considerably easier to find than most of the limited releases above.

Read our Larceny Barrel Proof C923 review

Honorable Mentions

Woodford Reserve Chocolate Whisper Redux | 8.1/10 | $99.99

I went into this one expecting the chocolate malt influence to overwhelm everything else. Instead, I found chocolate cake, coffee grounds, Tootsie Roll, caramel and oak, all delivered with considerably less heat than I anticipated. It's an unusual Woodford Reserve release that turned out much better than my expectations, although you're paying nearly $100 for a 375ml bottle.

Read our Woodford Reserve Chocolate Whisper Redux review

Maker's Mark Wood Finishing Series: The Heart Release | 7.9/10 | $75.00

Maker's Mark brought back its Wood Finishing Series with The Heart Release, and at 112 proof it drinks a lot like a close cousin of Maker's 46 Cask Strength. Sweet caramel, dates and dark chocolate jump out first, with brown sugar, oak, cacao nibs and a run of cinnamon and allspice behind them. It is the most findable bottle in this whole list, which counts for plenty.

Read our Maker's Mark The Heart Release review

Final Thoughts

If there's one thing this list should demonstrate, it's that spending more money doesn't automatically get you better whiskey. Some of these bottles can compete with releases costing several hundred dollars, provided you can actually find them at retail.

And that's the catch. Tanyard Hill Rye, Stagg Jr Single Barrel and A. Smith Bowman Cask Strength are outstanding bottles, but they're not exactly waiting around on every liquor store shelf.

For someone who wants a good whiskey without spending months hunting, I'd point them toward Russell's Reserve Single Barrel, Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye or Larceny Barrel Proof. They're easier to track down, deliver plenty of flavor for the money, and don't require you to pay some ridiculous markup just to find out whether they're any good.

As always, buy what you enjoy, not what somebody else tells you to chase.

More from Bourbon Culture: check what allocated bottles are actually worth in the Bourbon Brown Book, find a bottle for someone with the Bourbon Gift Finder, see what is releasing next on the Bourbon Release Calendar, browse every scored review on our Reviews by Rating page, or go down a rung to our best bourbons under $35.

One Comment

  1. why include current releases you really can't find anywhere near sub $100 like Bowman Cask without a lottery win, or Tanyard Hill. Or can't find on a shelf, like old label style ECBP ? Maybe ER12 too ? I've never seen on a shelf. Woodford "chocolate whisper" is distillery only and therefore sure to be long gone to auction only.

    I'm all for anything you suggest that a reader can actually FIND (regional distribution questions aside). "modern" ECBP letter/3digits, Makers variants RR single (no Knob 12 ?) Your reviews of these are universal and consistent - tenths of a point aside - always good, always value." I'd argue that is what readers of this headline want, not auction items not found or afforded.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *